Best Pizza in Flatiron NYC: Nestled in the heart of New York City, the Flatiron District is home to some of the city’s best pizza spots. From classic New York-style slices to gourmet pies, the variety and quality of pizza in this vibrant neighbourhood will satisfy any craving. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice on the go or sitting down to savour every bite, there’s a pizzeria for every taste in Flatiron.
Table of contents
1. Lupetto
Located in the heart of Flatiron, Lupetto is a cosy Italian eatery that delivers a slice of rustic Italy to New York City. With a warm and inviting ambience featuring exposed brick walls, wooden furnishings, and soft, dim lighting, Lupetto feels both modern and timeless. The atmosphere is perfect for date nights or small gatherings with friends. Lupetto specialises in thin-crust pizzas made in a wood-fired oven, which lends a perfectly crisp texture and a subtle smoky flavour to each pie. Their pizzas highlight high-quality ingredients imported directly from Italy, like San Marzano tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella, and hand-picked basil.
Among their must-try dishes is the Margherita Pizza, which perfectly balances tangy tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and fresh basil. For meat lovers, the Prosciutto di Parma Pizza is a winner, topped with salty prosciutto and arugula. Pair your pizza with a glass of wine from their curated Italian wine list for a complete experience. Whether you’re a pizza purist or looking to try something new, Lupetto has something for everyone.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Rustic, Cosy, Modern |
| Specialities | Thin-crust, Wood-fired Pizza |
| Must-try Dishes | Margherita, Prosciutto Pizza |
| Ideal for | Date nights, small groups |
2. Tappo
Tappo, a local favourite in Flatiron, is renowned for its perfectly thin-crust pizzas that delight pizza lovers of all types. The restaurant has a lively yet laid-back vibe, with a modern interior accented by clean lines, large windows, and an inviting bar area. It’s an excellent spot for lunch with coworkers or casual dinners with friends. The menu offers a range of inventive pizzas with a focus on high-quality ingredients and bold flavours. Tappo’s thin-crust pizza is crafted to have the perfect crunch without being overly dry or brittle.
One of their standout dishes is the Tappo Special Pizza, a flavourful combination of pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and bell peppers that satisfies every craving. Vegetarians can enjoy the Mushroom & Truffle Pizza, where the rich earthiness of mushrooms pairs harmoniously with fragrant truffle oil. Tappo also offers a variety of salads and small plates, making it easy to enjoy a balanced meal. Don’t forget to pair your pizza with one of their refreshing craft beers or signature cocktails.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Modern, Casual, Lively |
| Specialities | Thin-crust Pizza |
| Must-try Dishes | Tappo Special, Trufle Pizza |
| Ideal for | Casual dining, groups |
3. Zero Otto Nove
Zero Otto Nove brings a taste of Southern Italy to NYC, offering authentic Neapolitan-style pizza with rich, bold flavours. The restaurant’s ambience is reminiscent of a charming Italian trattoria, with rustic decor, dim lighting, and a relaxed yet elegant atmosphere. Perfect for family dinners or romantic evenings, Zero Otto Nove delivers on both quality and comfort. Pizzas here are baked in a traditional wood-fired oven, achieving that classic Neapolitan char and fluffy crust with a slightly chewy bite. This place has the best pizza in Flatiron, NYC.
The Margherita D.O.C. is a crowd favourite, made with San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella di bufala, and fresh basil. Another popular option is the Quattro Formaggi Pizza, featuring a luxurious blend of four cheeses, including mozzarella, gorgonzola, fontina, and parmesan. For those looking for variety, the menu also includes homemade pasta, antipasti, and fresh seafood. Zero Otto Nove’s extensive wine list ensures you’ll find the perfect pairing for your meal.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Rustic, Elegant, Relaxed |
| Specialities | Neapolitan-style Pizza |
| Must-try Dishes | Margherita D.O.C., Quattro Formaggi |
| Ideal for | Family dining, romantic nights |
4. Norma
Norma is a charming Italian pizzeria in the Flatiron area that specializes in crafting Neapolitan-style pizzas with an emphasis on traditional recipes. The restaurant’s decor is a blend of contemporary and rustic, featuring wood accents, cosy seating, and a welcoming vibe that feels like a slice of Italy. Perfect for both small groups and intimate dinners, Norma’s ambience is as delightful as its cuisine. The pizzas are made with high-quality, fresh ingredients, and cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven for that authentic Neapolitan flavour.
The Diavola Pizza is a must-try, with spicy soppressata and chilli oil adding a fiery kick to each bite. Another standout is the Capricciosa Pizza, topped with artichokes, olives, mushrooms, and prosciutto cotto. To complete your meal, explore Norma’s curated selection of Italian wines and craft beers. Guests also rave about the restaurant’s excellent service and attention to detail, making it a memorable experience.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Cosy, Rustic, Modern |
| Specialities | Neapolitan-style Pizza |
| Must-try Dishes | Diavola, Capricciosa |
| Ideal for | Small groups, date nights |
5. La Pizza & La Pasta (Eataly)
Located inside the iconic Eataly NYC, La Pizza & La Pasta is a destination for lovers of Italian cuisine. With a bustling and vibrant atmosphere, it captures the essence of a modern Italian marketplace. The restaurant offers a mix of pizzas and handmade pasta, focusing on fresh, authentic ingredients imported straight from Italy. The open-kitchen concept allows guests to watch skilled chefs stretch and toss dough, creating artisanal pizzas with precision and flair.
The La Margherita Classica is a standout choice, featuring fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomato sauce, and fragrant basil. For something unique, try the Tartufo Pizza, topped with seasonal truffles and fontina cheese. In addition to pizzas, their handmade pasta dishes like the Tagliatelle al Ragu are also crowd favourites. Pair your meal with a crisp Italian wine or a signature aperitivo to round out your dining experience. With its vibrant energy and exceptional food, La Pizza & La Pasta is a must-visit.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Bustling, Vibrant, Market-style |
| Specialities | Artisanal Pizza, Handmade Pasta |
| Must-try Dishes | La Margherita Classica, Tartufo Pizza |
| Ideal for | Families, casual dining |
Also Read:
6. Scarr’s Pizza
Scarr’s Pizza is a retro-inspired pizzeria that combines old-school New York charm with high-quality ingredients. Located just a short distance from Flatiron, Scarr’s has gained a cult following for its no-nonsense approach to pizza. The atmosphere feels nostalgic, with vintage decor, classic booths, and a casual, laid-back vibe. This is a place where the focus is on the food, and it delivers every time. Scarr’s uses house-milled flour and organic ingredients to create pizzas that are flavourful, fresh, and satisfying.
The Classic Pepperoni Pizza is a fan favourite, with crispy, curled pepperoni and a perfectly chewy crust. For something unique, try the Vegan Pizza, which caters to plant-based eaters without sacrificing taste. Scarr’s also serves slices for those on the go, and their homemade garlic knots are the perfect snack or side dish. Whether you sit down for a full pie or grab a quick slice, Scarr’s Pizza is a must-visit for New York-style pizza lovers.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Retro, Casual, Nostalgic |
| Specialities | Classic NY-style Pizza |
| Must-try Dishes | Classic Pepperoni, Vegan Pizza |
| Ideal for | Quick bites, casual dining |
7. San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina
San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina brings the flavours of Naples to New York City. Known for its Neapolitan-style pizza, this cosy and inviting restaurant offers an authentic Italian experience. The interior is intimate and welcoming, with wood-fired ovens adding a warm, rustic touch to the atmosphere. It’s the perfect spot for a laid-back dinner with friends or a family outing.
The Margherita Pizza is a standout, boasting a soft and airy crust with a balanced mix of tangy tomato sauce, mozzarella, and fresh basil. For seafood lovers, the Frutti di Mare Pizza is a must-try, topped with shrimp, clams, and calamari. San Matteo also serves a variety of Italian appetizers and handmade pasta, so there’s something for everyone. Pair your meal with a glass of Italian wine or a refreshing Aperol Spritz for the full experience.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Cosy, Rustic, Intimate |
| Specialities | Neapolitan-style Pizza |
| Must-try Dishes | Margherita, Frutti di Mare |
| Ideal for | Family outings, friends |
8. Olio e Piú
Olio e Piú is a charming trattoria in Greenwich Village, just a short trip from Flatiron. Known for its inviting European-style ambience and artisanal pizzas, Olio e Piú has become a favourite among pizza connoisseurs. The restaurant’s design features exposed brick walls, wooden beams, and a cosy patio, making it perfect for romantic dinners and special occasions.
Their Tartufo Pizza is the highlight, featuring truffle cream, mozzarella, and black truffles, creating an indulgent and luxurious flavour profile. Another standout is the Quattro Formaggi, which combines four rich cheeses for a creamy, savoury experience. In addition to pizzas, Olio e Piú serves handmade pasta, antipasti, and decadent desserts like tiramisu. The restaurant also boasts a fine selection of wines and cocktails, ensuring a well-rounded dining experience.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Romantic, Rustic, Cosy |
| Specialities | Artisanal Pizzas |
| Must-try Dishes | Tartufo Pizza, Quattro Formaggi |
| Ideal for | Date nights, special occasions |
9. Posto Thin Crust Pizza
Posto Thin Crust Pizza is the go-to spot for those who love their pizza light, crispy, and loaded with flavour. Located in the Flatiron area, this casual eatery offers a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, with simple decor that keeps the focus on the food. The restaurant prides itself on its signature thin crust, which provides the perfect base for an array of creative toppings.
One of their must-try pizzas is the Shroomtown Pizza, loaded with mushrooms, garlic, and a sprinkle of fresh herbs. Another favourite is the Sausage & Peppers Pizza, which combines savoury Italian sausage with sweet bell peppers for a satisfying bite. Posto also caters to gluten-free diners, offering a gluten-free crust option that doesn’t compromise on taste. Pair your pizza with a craft beer or a house-made sangria to complete the meal.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Casual, Relaxed |
| Specialities | Thin-crust Pizzas |
| Must-try Dishes | Shrromtown, Sausage & Peppers |
| Ideal for | Groups. Gluten-free diners |
10. Pizza Suprema
Pizza Suprema, located just steps from Madison Square Garden, is a no-frills pizza joint that has been serving New Yorkers since 1964. Known for its classic slices and traditional New York-style pies, Pizza Suprema focuses on delivering quality pizza without the fuss. The ambience is simple and functional, making it ideal for a quick and satisfying meal.
Their Classic Cheese Slice is a standout, featuring perfectly melted mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and a foldable, chewy crust. For a more loaded option, the Suprema Special combines pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, and mushrooms for a hearty, flavour-packed experience. Pizza Suprema is also loved for its consistency, with every slice made fresh and served piping hot. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite on the go or sitting down for a full pie, this iconic pizzeria delivers on all fronts.
| Details | Information |
| Ambience | Simple, Functional |
| Specialities | NY-style Pizza |
| Must-try Dishes | Classic Cheese Slice, Suprema Special |
| Ideal for | Quick meals, pizza enthusiasts |
Also Read:
In a city known for its pizza, the Flatiron District stands out as a hub for delicious, diverse, and memorable pies. Whether you’re a fan of classic styles or adventurous toppings, these pizzerias offer something special. So, the next time you’re in the area, make sure to grab a slice—your taste buds will thank you! For booking the best student accommodation abroad to start your study abroad experience you can contact Fly Homes at 1800572118.
Check Out These Great Finds in New York
FAQs
Some top choices include Prince Street Pizza, Lombardi’s Pizza, Eataly’s Pizza (inside the marketplace), Marty’s V Burger, and Talia’s Pizza.
Yes, Lombardi’s Pizza, often considered one of the first pizzerias in the U.S., serves delicious New York-style pizza in the Flatiron area.
Prince Street Pizza is known for its signature thick and crunchy Sicilian slices topped with pepperoni. Eataly also offers speciality pizzas with unique toppings like truffle and various gourmet ingredients.
Talia’s Pizza is highly recommended for its classic Margherita pizza, made with fresh mozzarella, basil, and a perfect crust.
Yes, Eataly’s Pizza serves Neapolitan-style pizzas with a soft and airy crust, made with high-quality, traditional ingredients.
Many locals praise Marty’s V Burger for its thin, crispy crust. Prince Street Pizza is also known for its delicious, crunchy crust on Sicilian slices.
Yes, Eataly offers a variety of vegetarian pizzas, including options with fresh vegetables, mushrooms, and ricotta. Talia’s Pizza also has several vegetarian options.
Prince Street Pizza is one of the most famous spots for pizza by the slice in the Flatiron area, particularly their signature pepperoni slices.
Most of the top pizzerias in the Flatiron District, including Lombardi’s Pizza and Talia’s Pizza, offer delivery and takeout services.
Pizza in the Flatiron District can range from USD 3 for a basic slice to USD 20 or more for a full pie with gourmet toppings. Popular spots like Prince Street Pizza offer slices at about USD 5–USD 7, while sit-down pizzerias like Eataly might charge USD 15–USD 25 for a full pizza.
Follow Us on Social Media
