New York City is synonymous with iconic sights, vibrant culture, and of course, mouthwatering pizza. Times Square, the bustling heart of Manhattan, is home to some of the finest pizzerias in the city, offering an eclectic mix of flavours, styles, and atmospheres. Whether you’re a tourist looking for a quick bite between sightseeing or a local in search of a reliable slice, Times Square’s pizza scene has something for everyone. In this guide, we explore ten exceptional pizzerias that capture the essence of New York pizza. From traditional thin-crust slices to inventive speciality pies, these establishments are guaranteed to satisfy your pizza cravings.
Table of contents
1. Joe’s Pizza
Joe’s Pizza is an iconic name in the New York pizza scene, and its location near Times Square makes it a must-visit for tourists and locals alike. Founded in 1975, this pizzeria is celebrated for its traditional New York-style thin-crust pizza. The ambience is simple and casual, reminiscent of classic pizza joints, with limited seating that encourages grab-and-go dining. The walls are adorned with photos of celebrities who’ve visited, adding a touch of charm.
Specialities at Joe’s Pizza include the classic cheese slice, which boasts a perfectly crispy crust, tangy tomato sauce, and gooey mozzarella cheese. Their pepperoni slice is another favourite, featuring generous toppings and just the right amount of spice. For those looking for something slightly different, the white pizza, with its creamy ricotta and garlic base, is a delight.
Joe’s Pizza is also highly regarded for its consistency and quality. Despite being a busy spot, they ensure every slice is fresh and delicious. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite before a Broadway show or taking a break from sightseeing, Joe’s Pizza provides a quintessential New York pizza experience.
| Feature | Details |
| Specialities | Cheese Slice, Pepperoni, White Pizza |
| Ambience | Casual, Quick Service |
2. Little Italy Pizza
Little Italy Pizza offers a slice of traditional Italian-American charm right in the heart of New York City. Known for its wide variety of pizza options, this spot is perfect for anyone seeking a classic New York-style pie with a touch of Italian authenticity. The interiors are straightforward and functional, making it a convenient spot for a quick meal.
The menu features everything from plain cheese slices to elaborate speciality pizzas. One of the must-try items is the Margherita pizza, made with fresh mozzarella, basil, and a zesty tomato sauce. Their Sicilian-style pizza is another standout, offering a thicker crust that’s light yet satisfying. The garlic knots served warm and buttery, are the perfect accompaniment.
Little Italy Pizza is a great spot for lunch breaks or a quick dinner. The staff is friendly, and the service is fast, ensuring you can enjoy your meal without delay. The portions are generous, making it a good value for the price. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or something more unique, Little Italy Pizza has you covered.
| Feature | Details |
| Specialities | Margherita, Sicilian Pizza, Garlic Knots |
| Ambience | Functional, Quick Service |
3. Carnegie Pizza
Nestled in the bustling streets near Times Square, Carnegie Pizza offers a no-frills dining experience with a focus on serving high-quality, fresh pizza. This spot caters to both the late-night crowd and those seeking a quick lunch, with its straightforward setup and efficient service. You can have the best cuisines in New York at this place.
Their menu features classic options like cheese and pepperoni slices, as well as more adventurous choices such as buffalo chicken pizza. The crust is a perfect balance of crisp and chewy, and the toppings are always fresh and generously applied. Carnegie Pizza also offers calzones and strombolis, making it a versatile choice for any pizza lover.
In addition to its pizza offerings, Carnegie Pizza provides a range of beverages, including sodas and beer, to complement your meal. Its central location and extended hours make it a convenient stop for tourists exploring Times Square or locals enjoying a night out.
| Feature | Details |
| Specialities | Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Calzones |
| Ambience | Casual, Quick Bite |
4. Patzeria Perfect Pizza
Patzeria Perfect Pizza is a hidden gem tucked away in Times Square, beloved for its no-nonsense approach to classic New York pizza. With its unpretentious vibe and compact interior, it’s a popular spot for those looking for a quick slice in between sightseeing or a pre-theatre meal.
Known for its thin crust, Patzeria’s pizzas are consistently fresh and flavourful. The Grandma slice, with its square shape, crispy base, and rich tomato sauce, is a must-try. Another favourite is the meat lover’s pizza, piled high with sausage, pepperoni, and bacon. The garlic knots and side salads round out a satisfying meal.
Patzeria also caters to those with dietary restrictions, offering gluten-free crusts upon request. The friendly staff and cosy atmosphere make it a welcoming place to enjoy a slice of authentic New York pizza.
| Feature | Details |
| Specialities | Grandma Slice, Meat Lover’s Pizza |
| Ambience | Compact, Quick Service |
Also Read:
5. Carmine’s Italian Restaurant
Carmine’s Italian Restaurant is a landmark eatery in Times Square that offers an upscale yet family-friendly dining experience. Known for its traditional Italian-American dishes, this restaurant also serves up delicious pizzas that are perfect for sharing. The spacious interiors, adorned with vintage photographs and warm lighting, create a welcoming atmosphere for groups and families.
The pizzas at Carmine’s are made with high-quality ingredients, including fresh mozzarella, homemade tomato sauce, and hand-tossed dough. Their Margherita pizza is a favourite, featuring a thin crust topped with vibrant basil and melted cheese. For those seeking something heartier, the meatball pizza is a must-try, offering rich flavours and generous portions.
Carmine’s also boasts an extensive wine and cocktail list, making it a great spot for celebrations or special occasions. With its combination of excellent service, flavourful food, and inviting ambience, Carmine’s is a top choice for a memorable dining experience in Times Square.
| Feature | Details |
| Specialities | Margherita Pizza, Meatball Pizza |
| Ambience | Family-friendly, Upscale |
6. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza is a well-loved chain known for its indulgent and creative pizza offerings. Located just a short distance from Times Square, this spot is perfect for those seeking bold flavours and hearty portions. The interiors are cosy and vibrant, with a lively atmosphere that’s ideal for casual dining.
Their signature artichoke pizza is a crowd favourite, featuring a creamy, spinach-and-artichoke base topped with mozzarella. Another standout is the crab pizza, which combines fresh seafood with a rich, garlicky sauce. For those who prefer classic flavours, the margherita and pepperoni pizzas are equally satisfying.
Artichoke Basille’s also offers a selection of beer and wine, making it a great place to unwind with friends. The generous slices and unique flavour profiles have earned it a dedicated following, making it a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.
| Feature | Details |
| Specialities | Artichoke Pizza, Crab Pizza |
| Ambience | Cosy, Casual |
7. Capizzi
Capizzi is a family-owned pizzeria that brings the authentic flavours of Naples to Times Square. This wood-fired pizzeria emphasises fresh, high-quality ingredients and traditional recipes. The rustic décor, complete with exposed brick walls and warm lighting, creates a charming and intimate dining atmosphere.
The menu at Capizzi features a variety of wood-fired pizzas, including the classic Margherita and the signature Capizzi pizza, topped with prosciutto, arugula, and shaved Parmesan. Vegetarian options, like the roasted vegetable pizza, are also available. Pair your meal with a glass of wine from their curated list for a truly Italian experience.
Capizzi’s dedication to quality and authenticity has made it a favourite among locals and visitors alike. With its welcoming staff and cosy vibe, it’s the perfect spot for a leisurely meal or a romantic dinner.
| Feature | Details |
| Specialities | Wood-fired Pizza, Capizzi Pizza |
| Ambience | Rustic, Cosy |
8. Emmy Squared
Emmy Squared is a trendy pizzeria that specialises in Detroit-style square pizzas. Located in the vibrant area near Times Square, this eatery combines bold flavours with an innovative approach to pizza-making. The industrial-chic interiors, complete with communal seating and modern accents, provide a lively and inviting atmosphere. It is one of the best lunch spots in New York if you are in the mood for some Italian delicacy.
The menu features a variety of square pizzas, including the popular “Colony” pizza, topped with pepperoni, pickled jalapeños, and honey. Another standout is the “Big Ang,” featuring ricotta, mushrooms, and truffle oil. Emmy Squared also offers a range of non-pizza options, such as their famous “Le Big Matt” burger and crispy waffle fries.
With its creative menu and laid-back vibe, Emmy Squared is a great spot for group outings or casual date nights. Don’t forget to pair your meal with one of their craft beers or signature cocktails for the ultimate dining experience.
| Feature | Details |
| Specialities | Detroit-style Pizza, Colony Pizza |
| Ambience | Trendy, Casual |
9. Vito’s Slices & Ices
Vito’s Slices & Ices is a hidden treasure in the Times Square area, offering a unique combination of classic New York pizza and refreshing Italian ice. This small, family-run establishment is known for its friendly service and relaxed atmosphere, making it a favourite among locals.
The pizza menu includes classic options like cheese and pepperoni, as well as speciality slices such as the “Grandma” and “Chicken Bacon Ranch.” The crust is thin and crisp, providing the perfect base for their flavourful toppings. For dessert, try one of their homemade Italian ices, available in a variety of fruity flavours.
Vito’s is an excellent choice for a quick and satisfying meal. The affordable prices and high-quality food make it a great value, and its convenient location makes it a popular stop for both tourists and New Yorkers on the go.
| Feature | Details |
| Specialities | Grandma Slice, Italian Ices |
| Ambience | Family-friendly, Relaxed |
Also Read:
Times Square’s pizza scene is as diverse and vibrant as the city itself, offering a slice for every taste and occasion. From the traditional New York-style pizzas of Joe’s Pizza and Little Italy Pizza to the unique offerings at Artichoke Basille’s and Emmy Squared, these ten establishments showcase the best of what the area has to offer. Whether you’re seeking a casual grab-and-go experience or a cosy sit-down meal, these pizzerias provide a taste of New York that will leave a lasting impression.
Next time you find yourself in Times Square, make sure to indulge in one of these iconic pizza spots and savour the flavours that make New York a pizza lover’s paradise. For booking the best student accommodation abroad to start your study abroad experience you can contact Fly Homes at 1800572118.
Check Out These Great Finds in New York
FAQs
New York-style pizza is characterised by its thin, foldable crust, balanced tomato sauce, and a generous layer of mozzarella cheese. It’s often sold by the slice and cooked in a high-temperature oven, which gives it its signature texture and flavour.
Joe’s Pizza is renowned for its classic cheese slice, making it a must-visit for those seeking an authentic New York pizza experience.
Yes, several pizzerias, such as Patzeria Perfect Pizza, offer gluten-free crust options to cater to dietary restrictions.
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza is known for its creamy artichoke pizza and crab pizza, while Emmy Squared specialises in Detroit-style square pizzas with creative toppings.
Absolutely. Many pizzerias, including Capizzi and Carmine’s Italian Restaurant, offer vegetarian options like Margherita or roasted vegetable pizzas.
Prices vary from budget-friendly slices at places like Little Italy Pizza to more upscale dining experiences at Carmine’s, which offers larger pies and Italian entrees.
Yes, restaurants like Carmine’s Italian Restaurant and Capizzi have spacious seating and a family-friendly atmosphere, making them ideal for group dining.
Many pizzerias in the Times Square area, including Joe’s Pizza and Little Italy Pizza, offer delivery services through apps like Uber Eats, DoorDash, or their websites.
Carnegie Pizza is a great option for late-night cravings, thanks to its extended hours and central location.
While most pizzerias in Times Square operate on a walk-in basis, upscale spots like Carmine’s may require reservations during peak hours or for large groups.
Follow Us on Social Media
